Search
  • Home
  • The legal risks of getting workplace alcohol testing wrong
  • The legal risks of getting workplace alcohol testing wrong

    Rhys Evans of ALCO-Safe

    By Rhys Evans, Managing Director at ALCO-Safe

    For many South African businesses, workplace alcohol policies are designed with the best intentions: to protect safety, maintain productivity, and reduce risk. But when these policies are not backed by proper procedures and reliable evidence, they can quickly become a liability.

    A Labour Court ruling delivered on 10 October 2025 has brought this into sharp focus. In the case of Unilec SA (Pty) Ltd v Mahlo and Others, https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZALCJHB/2025/467.html an employee dismissed for allegedly being under the influence of alcohol successfully challenged the decision at the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) and again in court. The outcome came down to one critical issue: the employer could not prove its case.

    This is where many organisations get it wrong.

    When suspicion is not enough

    The Labour Court upheld the commissioner’s assessment of the evidence in that particular dispute. The judgment records that two doctors had confirmed the employee was ill, that the employer had not submitted sufficient evidence of intoxication, and that an invoice for tests did not establish their results.

    In this case, the employer relied largely on allegation rather than proof. No verified test results were presented during the CCMA proceedings and attempts to introduce additional evidence later at the Labour Court stage were rejected. As the judge noted, a case cannot be strengthened with evidence that was never formally submitted in the first place. The dismissal was found to be both procedurally and substantively unfair.

    The growing risk for employers

    Employers can face disputes where policies are unclear or procedures are applied inconsistently. The evidence required depends on the charge, the facts and the applicable legal framework. Evans argues that employers should document their processes and the evidence supporting any disciplinary action.

    What defensible action looks like

    A defensible alcohol policy rests on three pillars: clarity, consistency, and evidence. It begins with a clearly documented policy outlining acceptable behaviour, testing protocols, and disciplinary procedures, all of which must be communicated to employees and supported by a structured process that is applied consistently.

    Most importantly, the policy must be backed by reliable testing. Evans recommends starting with a screening test using a calibrated breathalyzer https://alcosafe.co.za/products/alcohol-testing-breathalysers . If the employee fails, this should be followed by a confirmation process. This includes a waiting period to eliminate residual mouth alcohol, followed by at least one, and ideally two, confirmation tests.

    Each step must be properly documented. Time stamps, test results, and adherence to procedure form part of the evidentiary record. Without this level of rigour, even justified disciplinary action can unravel.

    Why the right tools matter

    Not all breathalyzers https://alcosafe.co.za/products/alcohol-testing-breathalysers are equal, and in a legal dispute, the reliability of the device used can be as important as the result itself. Evidentiary-grade breathalyzers https://alcosafe.co.za/products/alcohol-testing-breathalysers , supported by valid calibration certificates, can contribute to the evidentiary record when correctly used.

    They turn testing into credible evidence. Equally important is how these tools are used, as even the best device can be undermined by poor handling, lack of training, or inconsistent application. This is why alcohol testing needs to be viewed as a system, not just a procedure.

    The unavoidable truth

    For many organisations, managing workplace alcohol risk https://alcosafe.co.za/services is not a core competency. Without the right expertise, drafting policies, procedures, and testing frameworks internally often leads to gaps. Partnering with an experienced provider can help close these gaps. From policy development and staff training to calibration and compliance support, a specialist approach ensures that drug and alcohol testing in the workplace https://alcosafe.co.za/services align with legal expectations.

    As recent case law shows, even small procedural oversights can escalate into significant legal challenges. Organisations that implement structured, defensible systems are far better positioned to withstand scrutiny and avoid costly disputes.

    In these situations, the question is not what an employer believed, but what they can prove. The outcome of any dispute depends on its facts, the evidence and the process followed.

    Portrait supplied by ALCO-Safe, reframed for publication.

    Facebook
    Twitter
    LinkedIn
    Pinterest